October 02, 2012

Mistresses, single women & the economy

Jin Yanshi knows how to get noticed.
Very recently, this Chinese economist came out with a theory implying that a women's marital status is key to a vigorous economy. According to his theory in China Times and Business Insider, the more the number of single women, the better it is for the economy. 

His hypothesis is cloaked with 3 assumptions: 
1) Women love money (as if men do not!)
2) Women love to spend money (and men are misers, is it?)
3) Women are born consumption animals (and men are not?)

Based on those assumptions, he pontificates on why consumption is such a distinctive element of the female psyche. “Women express their desire in competition" (who knew?). "This competition therefore promotes a city’s consumption.”

His theory: The more the "divorced" and "leftover" women (the latter being a term to describe singles over 28), the greater the chance of an economy's prosperity.
His reason: Their jostling with other females for attention and competing with one another only feeds their innate consumption desire. This, in turn, does wonders for domestic consumption. 

If China follows his theory, the decision makers don't have to worry about an alternative to their faltering export model which is hitting growth. They just need to ensure that their women marry late and encourage divorce. 

I was curious to see what he had to say about "leftover" men, if there is such a term. 
According to him, men who have NO spending power will NOT be able to find wives (he obviously is no romantic) and so will NOT contribute to the city's economy. 
His remedy: Kick them out of town (he failed to cite the destination). 

Yanshi surprisingly excluded ernai; a literal translation is second wife but it actually indicates a mistress. Mistresses are neither divorcees nor "leftovers" but are very much part of China's social landscape. According to a report in Yahoo Finance, Chinese men buying gifts for their ernai may be among the best customers for luxury goods. And the young ladies' designer wardrobes play host to labels like Jimmy Choo, Cartier, Versace, Prada, Chanel, Yves Saint Laurent and Louis Vuitton. For instance, a 42-year old property developer called Jian in the southern metropolis of Shenzhen claimed that his 20-something mistress set him back by $6,100/month. He referred to her as being an "expensive hobby like golf". Jian is not my sleight of hand or figment of my imagination. He actually was interviewed by The New York Times. 

So if infidelity is such a big contribution to China’s consumption story, am surprised that this set of women was ignored when concocting such a theory.

More worrisome now, for retailers, is whether this trend is dropping. During the credit crunch in 2009, CNN reported on how a businessman could not afford to keep his 4 mistresses, so he employed the services of a local modelling agency to stage a private talent show and judge the women on their looks, their singing ability and how much alcohol they could hold. The winner would stay his mistress. 
Moneyweek recently reported that nearly half of the 1,000 richest people in China saw their wealth shrink in the past year. While China's boom spurred a market for mistresses, the weakening economic growth is affecting that equation. According to a research note by HSBC, the practice of wealthy men acquiring mistresses is on the wane. Coupled with the fact that there is less official tolerance of wealthy government officials flaunting their "bling", the $12 billion luxury market is being hit. 

Even though the country's growth engine is spluttering and luxury sales are being hit, China's consumption boom is not fading into insignificance. Yahoo cites various reports to prove this point. A World Bank Report envisages per capita income rising to $16,000 by 2030 (from $5,000 now). The report also predicts that domestic consumption will shoot up to 2/3rd of economic activity. A McKinsey report reckons that China's mainstream consumer class will comprise 400 million people with household incomes between $16,000 and $34,000 by 2020. Boston Consulting Group says China will be the world's No. 2 consumer market by 2015. 

The Wall Street Journal says that China has a lot of tools to drive wealth and encourage investments. China is encouraging domestic demand and household spending in a bid to drive GDP growth and speed up economic restructuring. Encouraging growth in domestic consumption to find quality drivers for the economy was one of the key targets of China’s 12th 5-year-plan. The country is looking at potential reforms to boost investment and consumption in the areas of pension, healthcare, education, agricultural and land ownership, and continuing urbanization. 
Looks like the government is not taking Jin Yanshi too seriously. 

2 comments:

Concerned citizen said...

what a hilarious man - this Jin Yanshi. On a different note, in the UK, they are now taking cognizance of the "pink pound" - consumption by gay people as they spend every "healthily" on luxury items, fashion, doing up apartments etc. In India, we must do the same as well and also look into the consumption power of people with disabilities. For instance, all books must be printed in Braille, as blind people have good interest in reading, as well as pretty pockets. All these consumers have "specific" needs and cannot be ignored. So, if companies/ media houses etc are smart they will start widening their horizons. My two cents.

Zora said...

".....so he employed the services of a local modelling agency to stage a private talent show and judge the women on their looks, their singing ability and how much alcohol they could hold. The winner would stay his mistress."

Alright I am curious whether this sleazeball was going to pick the winner based on whether she could barely hold any alcohol or whether she could hold a great deal of alcohol....:):)

Post a Comment

Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.